Why do millions of willing-to-work Americans remain unemployed?
Or remain trapped in part-time, no-benefits jobs far below their levels of education and experience?
A major reason: The refusal of Congressional Republicans to create job opportunities for their fellow Americans.
U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders (I, Vermont) made just that argument to guest host Ezra Klein on the June 12, 2012 edition of “The Rachel Maddow Show.”
SANDERS: Everybody knows you have to invest in infrastructure. We can create millions of decent paying jobs in the long term and I speak as a former mayor, you obviously save money because you don’t have to do constant repairs as we’ve just seen.
The simple reason is I’m afraid that you have a Republican mindset that says, “Hmm, let`s see, we can repair the infrastructure, save money long time, create millions of jobs, bad idea. Barack Obama will look good. And we’ve got to do everything that we can to make Barack Obama look bad.”
Another reason for America’s unemployment miseries: Many employers have designed “hiring” systems that simply don’t work.
So says Peter Cappelli, the George W. Taylor professor of management at the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania. He is also the author of Why Good People Can’t Get Jobs: The Skills Gap and What Companies Can Do About It.
Amazon.com: Why Good People Can’t Get Jobs: The Skills Gap and What Companies Can Do About It
Employers often whine that they can’t find the talent they need. Today’s applicants, they claim, lack skills, education and even a willingness to work.
The truth is altogether different. According to Cappelli, the fault lies with employers, not job-seekers:
- Hiring managers create wildly inflated descriptions of the talents and skills needed for openings: “They ask for the moon.”
- Computer technology eliminates many qualified people for consideration when their resumés don’t match the inflated qualifications demanded by employers.
- Employers aren’t willing to pay for the education and skills they demand: “What they really want is someone young, cheap and experienced.”
- Online applicants are often told to name a salary expectation. Anyone who names a salary higher than what the company is willing to pay is automatically rejected. There’s no chance to negotiate the matter.
- About 10% of employers admit that the problem is that their desired candidates refuse to accept the positions at the wage level being offered.
- Employers are not looking to hire entry-level applicants right out of school. They want experienced candidates who can contribute immediately with no training or start-up time.
- Employers demand that a single employee perform the work of several highly skilled employees. One company wanted an employee to be an expert in (1) human resources, (2) marketing, (3) publishing, (4) project management, (5) accounting and (6) finance.
- When employers can’t find the “perfect candidate” they leave positions open for months. But if they were willing to offer some training, they might easily hire someone who could quickly take on the job.
- Companies have stopped hiring new college graduates and grooming them for management ranks. They no longer have their own training and development departments. Without systems for developing people, companies must recruit outsiders.
- Employers’ unrealistic expectations are fueled partly by their own arrogance. With more than three jobless people for every opening, employers believe they should be able to find these “perfect people.”
According to Cappelli, the hiring system desperately needs serious reform:
- Review job descriptions. If they’re inflated, bring them down-to earth.
- Don’t expect to get something for nothing–or next to it. Offer competitive salaries.
- Scrutinize the hiring process. Make sure that the automated systems aren’t screening out qualified candidates simply because they don’t have all the brass buttons in a row.
- Beef up the Human Resources section.
A 1996 cartoon by Ted Rall, the no-holds-barred cartoonist, entitled “Something for Nothing,” brilliantly sums up how most corporate “job creators” actually regard and treat their employees and applicants:
Cappelli worries that the complaints about a labor shortage caused by an unwilling, unskilled workforce will be repeated enough that they will be accepted as truth:
“It’s a loud story … that could become pernicious if it persists. It does have a blame-the-victim feeling to it. It makes people feel better. You don’t have to feel so bad about people suffering if you think they are choosing it somehow.”
But America can end this national disaster–and disgrace.
A policy based only on concessions–such as endless tax breaks for hugely profitable corporations–is a policy of appeasement.
And appeasement only whets the appetite of those appeased for even greater concessions.
It is past time to hold wealthy and powerful corporations accountable for their socially and financially irresponsible acts.
This solution can be summed up in three words: Employers Responsibility Act (ERA).
If passed by Congress and vigorously enforced by the U.S. Departments of Justice and Labor, an ERA would ensure full-time, permanent and productive employment for millions of capable, job-seeking Americans.
And it would achieve this without raising taxes or creating controversial government “make work” programs.
Such legislation would legally require employers to demonstrate as much initiative for hiring as job-seekers are now expected to show in searching for work.

ABC NEWS, BARACK OBAMA, BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS, CBS NEWS, CHINA, CNN, EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION, EMPLOYERS RESPONSIBILITY ACT, FACEBOOK, JOB CREATORS, LOS ANGELES TIMES, NEW YORK TIMES, PETER CAPPELLI, READERS DIGEST, REPUBLICANS, SENATOR BERNIE SANDERS, SLAVERY, TED RALL, THE RACHEL MADDOW SHOW, TWITTER, UNEMPLOYMENT, WASHINGTON POST, WHY GOOD PEOPLE CAN'T FIND JOBS
ENDING UNEMPLOYMENT: PART ONE (OF FOUR)
In Bureaucracy, Business, History, Law, Politics, Social commentary on March 10, 2014 at 12:01 amAmericans now consider unemployment the country’s Number 1 problem.
The finding comes in a Gallup poll conducted February 6-9.
Twenty-three percent now consider unemployment the greatest challenge facing the nation, while only 16% said the same in January.
Only 63% of working-age Americans are now employed or seeking work–the lowest share of the population making up the labor force since 1978.
Among the proposals offered for creating jobs:
Yet none of these proposed solutions addresses the single greatest reason for America’s continuing unemployment problem: The refusal of American employers to hire American job-seekers.
An article in the March, 2011 issue of Reader’s Digest gives the lie to the excuses so many employers use for refusing to hire.
Entitled “22 Secrets HR Won’t Tell You About Getting a Job,” it lays bare many of the reasons why America needs to legally force employers to demonstrate as much responsibility for hiring as job-seekers are expected to show toward searching for work.
Click here: 22 Secrets HR Won’t Tell You About Getting a Job | HT Staffing
Among the truths it reveals:
Millions of Americans continue to blame President Barack Obama for the nation’s high unemployment rate. But no President can hope to turn unemployment around until employers are forced to start living up to their responsibilities.
And those responsibilities should encompass more than simply fattening their own pocketbooks and/or egos at the expense of their fellow Americans. Such behavior used to be called treason.
It’s time to recognize that a country can be betrayed for other than political reasons. It can be sold out for economic ones, to
Employers who enrich themselves by weakening their country—by throwing millions of qualified workers into the street and moving their plants to other countries—are traitors.
Employers who set up offshore accounts to claim their American companies are foreign-owned—and thus exempt from taxes—are traitors.
Employers who systematically violate Federal immigration laws–to hire illegal aliens instead of willing-to-work Americans–-are traitors.
In its June 8, 2011 cover-story on “What U.S. Economic Recovery? Five Destructive Myths,” Time magazine warned that profit-seeking corporations can’t be relied on to ”make it all better.”
Click here: What U.S. Economic Recovery? Five Destructive Myths – TIME
Wrote Rana Foroohar, Time‘s assistant managing editor in charge of economics and business:
“There is a fundamental disconnect between the fortunes of American companies, which are doing quite well, and American workers, most of whom are earning a lower hourly wage now than they did during the recession.
“The thing is, companies make plenty of money; they just don’t spend it on workers here.
“There may be $2 trillion sitting on the balance sheets of American corporations globally, but firms show no signs of wanting to spend it in order to hire workers at home.”
In short: Giving even greater tax breaks to mega-corporations–the standard Republican mantra–has not persuaded them to stop “outsourcing” jobs. Nor has it convinced them to start hiring Americans.
While embarrassingly overpaid CEOs squander corporate wealth on themselves, millions of Americans can’t afford medical care or must depend on charity to feed their families.
Yet there is also a disconnect between the truth of this situation and the willingness of Americans to face up to that truth.
The reason:
“The Republicans have pulled off a major (some would say cynical) miracle,” writes Foroohar.
They have convinced “the majority of Americans that the way to jump-start the economy is to slash taxes on the wealthy and on cash-hoarding corporations while cutting benefits for millions of Americans.
“It’s fun-house math that can’t work. We’ll need both tax increases and sensible entitlement cuts to get back on track.”
Share this: